Loose Gutter Spikes

December 21, 2022

Downspout Clog Prevention

December 29, 2022

Published by Tony Waldron on December 27, 2022

ARE VINYL GUTTER SCREENS GOOD?

-PRODUCT REVIEW BY MY GUTTER DOCTOR-

vinyl gutter screen review

If you are interested in buying Vinyl Gutter Screens you WILL want to read this article first, so that you can make an educated and informed decision before purchasing.

In this article we discuss the pros and cons of Vinyl Gutter Screens, whether or not we recommend vinyl products or screens, and the reasonings why. Also included are photos of how these vinyl products actually hold up to gutter debris and the elements.

Cross section view of a Vinyl Gutter Screen on top of a K-Style gutter.

WHAT ARE VINYL GUTTER SCREENS

Gutter Screens, Gutter Covers, Gutter Helmets, Gutter Guards, etc. are all different names for Leaf Protection systems designed to keep leaves and other debris out of gutter systems. All styles of leaf protection vary slightly, so they each have their own various pros and cons.

new vinyl gutter screens

Vinyl Gutter Screens are gutter screens fabricated from PVC that snap-on to the tops of K-Style Gutters and slide under the shingles. The cheap price and easiness of installation make vinyl gutter screens a popular choice for new home owners.

There are 3 main types of Vinyl Gutter Screens that we are reviewing as one category because they all share the same negative features.

MICRO MESH VINYL GUTTER SCREENS

The most common style of vinyl gutter screens are called micro mesh and they feature a two part system. A rigid plastic frame (often with the diamond pattern pictured below) paired with a screen for filtering out smaller debris. In the photo below you see a classic example of vinyl gutter screens performing well against light pine needles and a couple leaves.

clogged vinyl gutter screens

SNAP IN OR EASY ON GUTTER SCREENS

These are basically the same as the micro mesh style pictured above, but without the extra screen layer to catch smaller debris. Not having the extra screen layer allows the water to flow into the gutter system more efficiently. This style can feature the diamond style holes or sometimes even circular holes.

vinyl gutter screens

VINYL GUTTER SCREEN ROLL

This may be the cheapest possible style of Leaf Protection on the market. It is basically a roll of plastic screen that is unrolled on tops of the gutters and then mounted down once in place. This style often comes with clips or hardware to prevent it from blowing off of the gutters. In order to have any luck with the rolls of screen you must secure them as good as possible to the gutters so that they do not blow away or cave into the gutters.

vinyl gutter screen roll kit

VINYL GUTTER SCREEN : PRO’S

LOW PRICE
READILY AVAILABLE
EASY INSTALLATION

Since all vinyl products are made from PVC (aka plastic) they are cheapest options of Leaf Protection (and gutter products) available. Plastic or vinyl gutter products will always be cheaper than aluminum products as they are manufactured at a cheaper price point, usually outside of the U.S.A.

Vinyl Gutter Screens can easily be found at Home Depot or Lowes, or even online through popular shopping apps like Amazon or Ebay.

Most styles of Vinyl Gutter Screens are Clip-On or Easy-On which means they easily clip onto the tops of the gutters without much effort or knowledge of gutters. An average homeowner that owns a ladder and is not afraid of heights would be able to install these with after watching a 2 minute you tube video.

VINYL GUTTER SCREEN : CON’S

LARGE HOLES – DEBRIS GETS INTO GUTTERS EASILY
EASILY COME LOOSE – DEBRIS GETS UNDER COVERS
BIRDS ARE ATTRACTED TO THIS STYLE BECAUSE OF THE GAPS
DAMAGES EASILY
SHORT LIFE SPAN
THE MESH SCREEN SEPARATES
TAMPERS WITH SHINGLES

Most styles of vinyl gutter screen have large sized holes. The problem with larger holes is the bigger the hole the bigger the debris that gets in. Larger debris such as seeds or seed pods are able to infiltrate the gutter system through vinyl gutter screens. If there is any decomposed material in the gutters the seeds are able to easily take root and grow in the fertile mix.

The purpose of leaf protection is to keep larger debris out of the gutter system. If the holes are large enough that seeds are able to get in and then take root, then that is a design failure. It basically creates a habitat for the plants to grow.

In the photo below you will see plants that have taken root and grown right through gutter screens. For root balls like this to develop and become fertile the gutter debris would need to be 6 months to a year old minimum.

plants grow through gutter screen

The problem with easy installation is that it also means easy removal! Unfortunately easy removal is not always a good thing.

Since vinyl screens slide onto the gutters without any mounting hardware, they easily come loose. Leaves and other debris are able to enter the gutter system through these gaps and get under the covers.

In the photo below you will see vinyl gutter screens installed along a roof edge. If you look down the line you will notice that every gutter screen is loose from the track on the far end. The gutter screen closest to the camera has “caved in” which creates a blockage in the gutter system. Once vinyl gutter screens begin to cave in like this they are actually causing more problems then good. A blockage or “dam” will form under this sunken in gutter screen that will keep getting worse and worse.

dirty vinyl gutter screens

debris in vinyl gutter screens

Since these are manufactured using vinyl/plastic you may have guessed that they are easily damaged and do not last very long. All vinyl gutter products damage easily and therefore are not recommend for gutter systems.

We never recommend any type of gutter screen that features a mesh screen or 2 part screen system. Over time the mesh screen will come unattached from the plastic frame which sometimes creates a pocket for debris to get stuck in. More and more debris wedges its way in there eventually forcing the gutter screen to completely separate and often blow off of the home.

mesh gutter screen damage

damaged gutter screen

Plant material that is left to rot and decompose while resting on gutter screens will stick to or “gunk up” the screens. Once gunk sticks to the screens water will sheen right over the screen and bypass the gutter system completely by overflowing the gutters.

Since the purpose of gutters is to collect the rain water and direct it away from the home’s foundation, water pouring directly over the gutters instead of going into the gutters makes them worthless.

If you look through all the photos on this page you will notice that the gutter screens go underneath the shingles. Since shingles are nailed and glued down to the roof decking, lifting them up or tampering with them in any way is never recommended. The idea is not to tamper with the roof as much as possible.

If gutter screens are not slid into place correctly, they will cause the shingles to bulge or stick up in these areas which causes splashing and potential water entry points under the roof.

DOES MY GUTTER DOCTOR RECOMMEND VINYL GUTTER SCREENS?

Unfortunately that’s going to be a “NO” from us. We would never recommend faulty products.

CONCLUSION:

IF DEBRIS IS ABLE TO GET IN, THE SCREENS ARE MORE PROBLEMATIC THEN HELPFUL

As we’ve previously mentioned the purpose of gutter screens is to prevent debris from entering the gutter system. If just one gutter cover is missing than debris is able to get in through the opening and clog any part of the system that is connected.

In the photo below you see a classic example of what happens under faulty gutter screens. If you look closely you notice there is an inch or two of dirt or mulch inside the gutters. This dirt is leaves that have already decomposed and turned to plant soil, ready to hatch seedlings. The couple inches of mulch indicates the gutters have been clogged a long time.